Oak Bluffs is still the least expensive town on Martha's Vineyard. Its entry price is no longer under $1 million, though. Between July 7 and Nov. 6, 2026, Oak Bluffs had about three dozen deed transfers in the weekly lists printed by The Martha's Vineyard Times and the Vineyard Gazette. Nine of those lines were under $1 million. Look closely at the nine and the plain story of a cheap house selling to a new owner fits only a few of them. The largest cluster of the town's sales fell between $1.0 million and $1.4 million. If you are comparing towns with a budget near seven figures, that band is where Oak Bluffs starts.
Last year, the town still had a sub-$1 million market
The 2025 numbers set the baseline. The MV Times 2025 market review counted 107 Oak Bluffs transactions for calendar year 2025, up from 96 in 2024. Forty-four of them were under $1 million, up from 39 the year before. The island as a whole had 100 sales under $1 million in 2025. Nearly half of them were in Oak Bluffs. In the same review, Oak Bluffs had the lowest average home price of any island town in 2025, at $1.38 million. Its 56 sales between $1 million and $3 million were the largest group in the town that year.
The review noted that the island's sub-$1 million segment fell every year after 2016 except 2020 and 2025, and that it made up a quarter of all island transactions in both 2024 and 2025. So 2025 was a good year for entry-level buyers, and Oak Bluffs accounted for 44 of those 100 sales.
The nine deeds under $1 million since July
These are the Oak Bluffs transfers under $1 million in the MV Times and Gazette weekly lists from early July through early November 2026.
| Recorded | Address as printed | Price | What the deed line shows |
|---|---|---|---|
| July 21 | 27 Island Inn Road, Unit 7 | $235,000 | A numbered unit |
| July 28 | 15 Second Ave. | $875,000 | A street address |
| Aug. 7 | 21 Kennebec Ave., Unit 1 | $640,000 | A unit, bought by Locals Only MV LLC |
| Sept. 2 | 22 Firehouse Lane | $905,000 | A street address |
| Sept. 8 | 66 Canonicus Ave. | $710,000 | A street address |
| Sept. 11 | Portion of 22 Franklin Ave. | $200,000 | Part of a property, bought by Steel & Vine LLC |
| Sept. 11 | Portion of 22 Franklin Ave. | $90,000 | A second part, same buyer |
| Oct. 23 | 26R Windemere Road | $750,000 | An undivided half-interest |
| Oct. 28 | 89 Pond View Drive | $550,000 | A transfer between two revocable trusts sharing a family name |
Three of the nine are plain street addresses with no unit, no partial interest and no matching trust names on both sides: 15 Second Avenue at $875,000, 22 Firehouse Lane at $905,000 and 66 Canonicus Avenue at $710,000. Two are numbered units. Two are pieces of one Franklin Avenue property going to the same buyer on the same day. One is half of a property on Windemere Road. The last one, 89 Pond View Drive, moved between two revocable trusts that share a family name. A transfer like that may not tell an outside buyer what the market would pay.
A $290,000 line for parts of one property, or a $550,000 trust-to-trust line, still lowers any average built from raw deed data. That is one reason a portal's "homes from $550K" filter can show Oak Bluffs as cheaper than it is for someone looking for a whole house. Before you count a sub-$1 million deed as a comparable sale, read the whole line.
The cluster between $1.0 and $1.4 million
Fourteen Oak Bluffs lines in the same window fell between $1.025 million and $1.39 million:
- 101 Tradewinds Road, $1.1 million
- 66 Barnes Road, $1.15 million
- 61D Ocean Avenue, $1.185 million
- 3 Kims Way, $1.188 million
- 66 Monroe Avenue, $1.2 million
- 82 Pennsylvania Avenue, $1.25 million
- 9 Brunswick Avenue, $1.275 million
- 66 Hudson Avenue, $1.296 million
- 5 Seth's Path, $1.325 million
- 27 Laurel Avenue, $1.375 million
- 13 Beach Road, $1.375 million
- 26 Sea Glen Road, $1.39 million
- 2 Winemack Street, $1.025 million
- 5 Circuit Avenue, $1.2 million
That is a wider spread than one neighborhood, from Ocean Avenue and Circuit Avenue in town to Barnes Road and Tradewinds Road farther out. The last address on that list had a business as seller. The Gazette reported that Murdick's Fudge Company of Massachusetts sold 5 Circuit Avenue to Cronig Family 5 Circuit LLC for $1.2 million on Oct. 5. If you leave that sale out, thirteen deeds still sit in a band about $400,000 wide. That is more than any other price range in the town's lists this fall, and more than the nine lines under $1 million.
Island-wide figures for the first half of 2026 show why buyers in that band have room to negotiate. The MV Times mid-year report found that 75 percent of island properties sold in the first half of 2026 closed below asking. Twenty-nine percent sold 1 to 5 percent under, 31 percent sold 6 to 10 percent under, 12 percent sold 11 to 20 percent under and 3 percent sold 21 to 33 percent under. In its own mid-year coverage, the Vineyard Gazette reported that the island's lower-priced homes were going through repeated price cuts. Brokers it spoke with said "low-end" homes now regularly top $1 million and often need substantial work. In Oak Bluffs, a $1.3 million asking price on a house that needs work leaves the most room for an offer.
The top of the town moved, too
This fall, the high end of Oak Bluffs looked more like Edgartown. 98 Farm Neck Way sold for $3.5 million on Sept. 30. 8 Paddock Road sold for $5.3 million on Oct. 2, and 385 Barnes Road sold for $5.208 million on Oct. 5. That is three sales over $3 million in one week. In all of 2025, Oak Bluffs had seven. Below that tier, 12 Samoset Avenue sold for $2.394 million, 50 Hidden Cove Road for $2.15 million, 25 Pennacook Avenue for $2.1 million and 312 East Chop Drive for $2.05 million.
According to the MV Times mid-year report, sales over $3 million made up 21 percent of island transactions and 55 percent of dollar volume in the first half of 2026, compared with 17 percent and 44 percent a year earlier. Island inventory at mid-year was 288 properties, down from 350 at mid-year 2025. With fewer listings island-wide and more of the dollar volume at the top, the Oak Bluffs lists this fall showed three whole-address sales under $1 million and thirteen other deeds between $1.0 and $1.4 million.
An employer bought on Windemere Road
On Sept. 14, Martha's Vineyard Hospital Inc. bought 33 and 35 Windemere Road for $1.7 million, according to the Gazette's transaction list. The hospital has been building and buying housing for its workforce for years. In 2024 the Vineyard Gazette reported hospital president Denise Schepici's statement that 250 of the hospital's 900 employees lived in housing it owned or leased. She described the goal as "controllable, affordable housing" for staff and said the hospital was renovating an adjacent Oak Bluffs home for employees. This July, Healthcare Design reported that the hospital's 48-unit employee development, finished in summer 2025, had a waiting list. Chief administrative officer Michael Cosgrove told the magazine that affordable housing had been a deciding factor for some recent hires.
For a private buyer near $1 million, the Windemere Road deed is a reminder that established island institutions also buy in this town. The 2025 review names local families and service workers among the buyers in the island's sub-$1 million segment. The $1.7 million price for two Windemere Road addresses is now one of the recorded sales any appraiser on that street will see.
The monthly cost behind the price
The Gazette's August coverage put a number on how hard the entry tier is to carry. Lower-priced island homes could mean mortgage payments of $7,000 to $8,000 a month even with 25 to 30 percent down, as reported in summer 2026. In Oak Bluffs, the most realistic whole-house purchase this fall was in the $1.1 million to $1.4 million range, so that monthly cost is the starting point. This is general market information, not legal, tax or financial advice, and your own figures should come from a lender or adviser who knows your situation.
On the Camp Ground, the price per square foot works differently again. Our look at what a $640,000 Camp Ground cottage actually buys covers how approval and leasehold ownership change that comparison. If you are deciding between in-town and the Chops, we compared downtown Oak Bluffs and East Chop on their own terms.
A few questions we hear often
Is Oak Bluffs still the island's most affordable town? On 2025 averages, yes. Its $1.38 million average home price was the lowest of the six towns for that year. This fall's deeds show the town's typical whole-house sale above $1 million.
Should a sub-$1 million deed be used as a comparable? Read the full transfer line before you rely on it. This fall the Oak Bluffs list included units, a half-interest, two partial parcels and a trust-to-trust transfer, and each of those can pull a simple average down.
Do buyers still get a discount? Island-wide in the first half of 2026, three of every four sales closed below asking. The Gazette reported that lower-priced homes were the ones seeing repeated price cuts.
If you are setting a budget for Oak Bluffs and want to know which recent deeds really match the house you have in mind, Studio Realty reads the transfer lists line by line every week. Request a private consultation, and we will go through this fall's Oak Bluffs sales with you street by street before you make an offer.