In late October, the Vineyard Open Land Foundation transferred land to Sheriff's Meadow Foundation. In Chilmark, that means Squibnocket Farm and Eddy Farm, plus a conservation restriction. The bigger change is in the market. The kind of deal that created these neighborhoods has mostly stopped happening, and VOLF said as much.
A new name on the land beside the lots
The MV Times reported that VOLF conveyed 256 acres to Sheriff's Meadow. The land covers Squibnocket Farm and Eddy Farm in Chilmark and Cranberry Acres, the organic cranberry bog in Vineyard Haven. VOLF also handed over four conservation restrictions covering 79 acres: two in West Tisbury, one in Chilmark and one in Edgartown. The Vineyard Gazette put the total at 335 acres and called it the largest conservation acquisition in Sheriff's Meadow's history. Before the gift, Sheriff's Meadow owned 2,493 acres and held 45 conservation restrictions over another 1,018.
Adam Moore, president of Sheriff's Meadow, told the Gazette that the foundation would "study them and write a management plan for how they'll be managed going forward." He described 2026 as a transition year. Eric Peters and Carol Magee of VOLF will keep advising on the properties. According to the MV Times, plans for Squibnocket Farm and Eddy Farm will be written "after time for ecological inventory, study, and consultation." No public-access plan has been announced for either Chilmark property.
The open question is how the land will be managed. Ecological plans for the land have not been written yet. For a homeowner whose view, road or beach access runs through that land, those plans matter.
How a VOLF neighborhood was put together
VOLF called itself a land-use planning organization. Sometimes it bought strategic parcels and then designed the plan, got it approved and carried it out. Sometimes it consulted for landowners, towns and neighborhood groups. Its own site says the conservation land in its projects may be managed by homeowners associations, towns or other conservation groups, not only by VOLF.
The basic idea was to build far fewer homes than zoning allowed and to keep most of the land open. VOLF's project pages give the numbers:
| Project | Town | Size | House lots | Conserved | Restriction managed by |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sweetened Water Farm, completed 1973 | Edgartown | 67 acres | 15, where zoning allowed 110 | 32 acres | Town of Edgartown and the HOA |
| Nat's Farm, completed 1981 | West Tisbury | 102 acres | 30, plus two youth lots | 56 acres | Sheriff's Meadow and the town |
| Peaked Hill, completed 1975 | Chilmark | 0.42 acres | None, a view site | Entire parcel | VOLF and the Town of Chilmark |
At Sweetened Water Farm, about half the acreage stayed open. In return, the property had only about one-seventh of the lots zoning would have allowed. The buyers of those 15 lots paid for a house site next to 32 protected acres, and they paid for the 95 houses that were never built. Much of a lot's value in a project like this depends on a recorded restriction on the neighboring land, and someone other than the lot owner holds that restriction.
The terms could also follow the buyer. A 2004 Vineyard Gazette report described five discounted "youth lots" that VOLF created inside the 180-acre Pilot Hill development on Lambert's Cove Road. The discounts came with terms attached, such as a ten-year commitment to stay and money owed back on an earlier departure. VOLF says it created 16 below-market residential sites for Islanders over its history.
Squibnocket Ridge, the Chilmark case
Squibnocket is VOLF's biggest Chilmark project, and accounts of it differ on the numbers. In a 2013 Vineyard Gazette account, the Hornblower estate and the Cape Cod Company asked VOLF in the early 1980s to draw a plan within the 390-acre Squibnocket Ridge area. A 20-lot subdivision was approved in 1991, and an adjacent 235 acres was given to VOLF in 1997. In 2018, VOLF chair Eric Peters told the MV Times that planning took "over 10 years." He gave the approval year as 1992, after review by Chilmark and the Martha's Vineyard Commission. He also said VOLF supervised the construction of roads and utilities and owned "over 200 acres" of conservation land there. This fall's transfer announcement says the project preserved 364 acres.
The figures differ because each account measures something different. They do agree on the basic setup. A limited number of private lots sit inside a large area of land that VOLF owned or restricted, and a homeowners association handles the residential side.
At Squibnocket, the HOA and the conservation landowner have dealt with each other directly. According to the 2013 Gazette account, the Squibnocket Farm homeowners association proposed buying 10.5 acres from VOLF and leasing them to Chilmark for a parking lot, as part of the beach and road access project. Eddy Farm shows the same kind of shared arrangement. In 2022, the MV Times reported that the property had been given to VOLF about 16 years earlier. The Eddy family kept an easement over the road, and an association agreed to maintain it.
Why no new neighborhoods like these are coming
VOLF's announcement explains why it stopped making new projects:
"Over the years, the changing nature of the Vineyard real estate market resulted in less planning opportunities for VOLF's work as larger parcels that came on the market were purchased by wealthy Vineyard summer residents as 'kingdom properties' and by the Martha's Vineyard Land Bank's ability to acquire parcels for preservation and public use."
That passage, quoted by the MV Times, names two kinds of buyers. VOLF's deals sat between them. A family selling a large tract could take a planned subdivision, with a few lots and the rest conserved. Today the same family can sell the whole tract to one buyer, or sell it for public use. Either way, there is less reason to subdivide.
The two buyers are also connected. The Land Bank is funded by a 2 percent fee on property transfers. The Gazette reported in July that the Land Bank brought in $15.38 million in fiscal year 2025, and that debt service makes up $9.6 million, or 68 percent, of its 2026 budget. Executive director James Lengyel said the fee "is ultimately insufficient" for everything the organization hopes to do. The fee rises with sale prices, so the island's most expensive sales help pay for the Land Bank's purchases. The Land Bank registrar's report for the week ending Oct. 16, 2026 shows $8,604,047.94 collected so far in fiscal 2027.
Those high-end sales have been setting records. In the first half of 2026, the island's median sale price hit a record $1.7 million and the average hit $2.7 million. There were 12 sales above $5 million, up from seven a year earlier, and six above $10 million, up from one. Sales over $3 million were nearly a quarter of all transactions and more than half of all dollars spent, according to the Vineyard Gazette's report on the LINK data. Chilmark's recent transfers follow the same pattern. The Gazette's weekly transfer columns list Chilmark sales of $6.5 million on Sept. 18 and $7 million on Sept. 24, and two more at $4.55 million each on Oct. 1 and Oct. 6.
So Chilmark's VOLF neighborhoods are a fixed set. The deals that created them came from a time when splitting a large tract into lots and open land made sense for the seller. They sit on top of the town's own rules, which our guide to Chilmark's 3-acre zoning covers. Our piece on what shapes property value in Chilmark gives more context.
What to ask for when a listing borders VOLF land
For a house in or next to a former VOLF project, these are worth requesting early:
- The conservation restriction itself. Ask who holds it now and who the co-holders are. At Nat's Farm, for example, VOLF lists Sheriff's Meadow and the town.
- The homeowners association documents. Find out what the association maintains, such as roads, beach areas or rare-plant zones, and how that work is paid for.
- Recorded covenants on the lot. These include building limits and any deed riders like the Pilot Hill youth-lot terms.
- Easements and agreements with the conservation landowner. Look for road rights, shared maintenance agreements like the one on Eddy Farm Road, or leases like the Squibnocket parking arrangement.
- Contact with Sheriff's Meadow. Ask about the timing of its management plan.
This is general information, not legal, tax or financial advice. Restriction and HOA terms differ by property, so have your own attorney review them before you commit.
A few questions we hear often
Is Squibnocket Farm open for public walking now? No public-access plan has been announced. Squibnocket Farm in Chilmark is also a separate property from the Squibnocket Pond Reservation in Aquinnah.
Does VOLF still own anything? The MV Times reported that VOLF still holds two small properties in Chilmark and Oak Bluffs, and Moore said those may also go to Sheriff's Meadow.
What happens to Cranberry Acres? The bog is in Vineyard Haven, and VOLF will supervise it for the rest of this year. After that, Sheriff's Meadow will run it entirely, according to the Gazette.
If you are weighing a home that borders conserved land in Chilmark, Studio Realty can help you gather the restriction, association and easement documents. Request a private consultation.